Tool Test: 18-Volt Drill/Drivers

Look for a fast, powerful tool with added features like a battery gauge and a light that stays on after the switch is released

17 MIN READ

Makita BDF451

StoryID
1858896
ToolNumber
11
ComponentId
tcm:78-1630437

Battery: 18 volts; 3.0 Ah
Battery gauge: No
Weight: 4.96 pounds
Lenght 9-3/16 inches
RPM 0–300; 0–600; 0–1,700
LED headlight: Dual lights above trigger; 10-second delay
Belt hook: Included
Web price: $280


Includes: Two batteries; charger; side handle; plastic case
Warranty: 3 years tool; 1 year battery and charger; 30-day satisfaction guarantee
Country of origin: China
Comments:—
Pro: Three-speed gear box; drill/drive mode separate from clutch; thin comfortable grip; bright dual-LED lights; includes belt hook; excellent fan-cooled charger; available as bare tool (BDF451Z)
Con: Feels somewhat top-heavy; trigger could be more responsive; no battery gauge

Metabo BS 18 LTX

StoryID
1858896
ToolNumber
12
ComponentId
tcm:78-1630437

Battery: 18 volts; 3.0 Ah
Battery gauge: Yes; on battery
Weight: 4.68 pounds
Lenght 8-7/16 inches
RPM 0–400; 0–1,400
LED headlight: On base; no delay
Belt hook: Not available
Web price: $285


Includes: Two batteries; charger; side handle; plastic case
Warranty: 1 year tool; 3 years battery and charger; 30-day satisfaction guarantee; register for XXL 3-year tool warranty
Country of origin: Germany
Comments:—
Pro: Feels powerful and well-made; mechanical clutch is paired with electronics that cut power to the motor at desired torque; dual side-mounted gear switches; sensitive trigger; fan-cooled charger
Con: Thick grip isn’t a good fit for smaller hands; no belt clip available; awkward battery release; only seven clutch settings

Milwaukee 2601-22

StoryID
1858896
ToolNumber
13
ComponentId
tcm:78-1630437

Battery: 18 volts; 1.5 Ah
Battery gauge: Yes; on battery
Weight: 3.82 pounds
Lenght 7-3/4 inches
RPM 0–350; 0–1,400
LED headlight: Above trigger; 8-second delay
Belt hook: Sold separately
Web price: $190


Includes: Two batteries; charger; blow-molded plastic case
Warranty: 5 years tool and charger; battery: 2 years or 1,000 charges (100%), 5 years or 2,000 charges (pro-rated); 30-day satisfaction guarantee
Country of origin: China
Comments:—
Pro: One of the more powerful compact models; comfortable grip; easy to shift gears; only compact with full metal chuck; available as bare tool (2601-20)
Con: Lowest clutch setting could be lower; trigger somewhat sloppy; does not include belt clip

Milwaukee 2610-24

StoryID
1858896
ToolNumber
14
ComponentId
tcm:78-1630437

Battery: 18 volts; 3.0 Ah
Battery gauge: Yes; on battery
Weight: 5.56 pounds
Lenght 9-1/4 inches
RPM 0–450; 0–1,800
LED headlight: Above trigger; no delay
Belt hook: Sold separately
Web price: $320


Includes: Two batteries; charger; side handle; blow-molded plastic case
Warranty: 5 years tool and charger; battery: 2 years or 1,000 charges (100%), 5 years or 2,000 charges (pro-rated); 30-day satisfaction guarantee
Country of origin: China
Comments:—
Pro: Feels very powerful; drill/drive mode separate from clutch; responsive trigger; thin comfortable grip; stiff metal side handle; available as bare tool (2610-20)
Con: One of the heavier models tested; does not include belt clip; side handle has only three positions: left, right, and up

Panasonic EY7450LR2S

StoryID
1858896
ToolNumber
15
ComponentId
tcm:78-1630437

Battery: 18 volts; 3.3 Ah
Battery gauge: No
Weight: 4.74 pounds
Lenght 8-9/16 inches
RPM 0–430; 0–1,650
LED headlight: On base; manually operated
Belt hook: Not available
Web price: $305


Includes: Two batteries; charger; side handle; plastic case
Warranty: 2 years tool; 1 year battery and charger; 30-day satisfaction guarantee
Country of origin: China
Comments:—
Pro: Good power; excellent runtime; thin comfortable grip; very responsive trigger; one of two models with 3.3-Ah batteries
Con: Manually activated light; no belt clip available; no battery gauge; overly large case; plastic chuck sleeve; limited number of tools in this battery system

Ridgid R86008K

StoryID
1858896
ToolNumber
16
ComponentId
tcm:78-1630437

Battery: 18 volts; 1.5 Ah
Battery gauge: Yes; on battery
Weight: 4.02 pounds
Lenght 7-1/4 inches
RPM 0–450; 0–1,650
LED headlight: On base; manual and automatic; 8-second delay
Belt hook: Included
Web price: $180


Includes: Two batteries; charger; side handle; soft zippered case
Warranty: 3 years tool, battery, and charger; register for lifetime coverage of tool, battery, and charger
Country of origin: China
Comments:—
Pro: Feels more powerful than average compact model; light can be activated by trigger or separate switch; only tool of its size that comes with a side handle
Con: One of the heavier compacts; soft case has no dividers to prevent contents from bouncing around; 3.0- Ah batteries available but can’t be purchased as part of kit

About the Author

Greg DiBernardo

“Passionate” is the best word that can be used to describe Greg DiBernardo. His professional world revolves around constructing beautiful outdoor spaces for his clients using cutting edge materials and methods that will stand the test of time.Greg is a nationally recognized figure in the deck building industry. He’s a regular contributor to the industry’s trade publication, Professional Deck Builder magazine, writing feature articles that dictate the deck and outdoor industry’s best practices for design, construction and management. He’s also a Contributing Editor for Tools of the Trade magazine and a frequent author for The Journal of Light Construction and Fine Home Building.He has been a presenter and speaker for the National Association of Remodelers (NARI) and large building supply companies on advanced deck building and business topics.A deck and construction industry insider, Greg’s notoriety affords him close personal connections with major industry manufacturers assisting them with product development, design and testing of new and existing building materials. Greg has also made TV appearances on the The Today Show, DIY Network, Extreme Makeover: Home Edition, House Smarts, and the Food Network. He resides in Canton, GA with his wife and daughter.

No recommended contents to display.